According to Fiddlesticks Country Club's 2024–25 membership packet, every property owner there must hold a Resident Equity membership. The initiation fee is $115,000, and $1 of it is refundable when the home is later sold. A few miles away in South Fort Myers, The Forest Country Club describes itself as a non-bundled community. Owning a home there does not require joining the club, and members do not have to live inside the gate.
That difference changes how a purchase at The Forest works. In a bundled club community, the buyer makes one decision and pays one combined price. At The Forest, the home is one negotiation and the membership is another. In late 2026 the buyer has room to negotiate in both, because the condo market and the club are each competing for buyers.
What a bundled club adds to the purchase
Fiddlesticks makes a useful comparison because it publishes its numbers. Its 2024–25 membership packet lists a separate $2,000 real estate transaction fee due at closing, on top of the initiation fee. As of October 1, 2024, the packet listed these monthly charges: $1,576 in operating dues, $290 in capital dues, $80 in Loch Ness dues and $44 in wastewater-treatment-plant dues. That comes to $1,990 a month. It also listed a food-and-beverage minimum of $1,600 per fiscal year. The packet says dues and fees can change without notice, so treat these as 2024–25 figures. They are not a 2026 quote.
The amounts matter less than how they behave. When joining is required, every future buyer of every home in the community also has to pay the club's entry cost, at whatever amount the club has set by then. That cost moves with the house from one owner to the next, and a buyer weighs it against the price the seller is asking. The home and the club are priced as one package, and no buyer can decline half of it.
Lee County's other club communities fall at different points between those two models. Wildcat Run's homeowners association FAQ says at least one owner of each lot or unit must be a Country Club Social Member, which is a social requirement rather than a golf requirement. The Gulf Harbour club's real estate page says residents do not have to join, and its club accepts both residents and non-residents. Buyers comparing Gulf Harbour and The Forest are therefore looking at two communities with the same structure. That makes the club's terms at each one part of the comparison.
These figures are general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Confirm current fees and your own obligations with the club, the association and your own advisors before you commit.
What The Forest asks of a buyer instead
The Forest has several membership tiers, and a household can choose among them or skip membership altogether. The club's membership page lists:
- Full Family Membership: unlimited golf on all 36 holes for the family, including dependents up to age 25.
- Individual Membership: unlimited golf for one designated golfer, with non-golf access for the spouse and family.
- Executive Membership: unlimited family golf for households where the eldest member is under 54.
- Limited Golf Membership: limited family golf during the six-month peak season and unlimited golf from May through October.
- Lifestyle Membership: clubhouse dining, tennis, pickleball, fitness and social events, with no golf.
- Racquets Membership: the tennis and pickleball center, plus club dining before 5 p.m.
The club does not post dollar amounts for these tiers. The membership page asks prospective members to call the office at (239) 482-1310 or use its inquiry form. In practice, a buyer gets the club's terms the same way they get a seller's price, by asking directly and negotiating.
The Limited Golf tier deserves a closer look from seasonal buyers. It gives unlimited golf in the six months when many seasonal owners are away and limited golf in the months they are here. A full-time resident who plays mostly in summer and a winter resident who plays three mornings a week would get very different value from the same tier. Only a non-bundled club can sell those two households different memberships.
The condo market under the gate
Most of the homes inside The Forest are condominiums, coach homes and villas. Single-family homes make up a smaller share. That puts most purchases there in the condo segment, which is the weaker of the two in the current Lee County data.
According to the Royal Palm Coast Realtor Association's October 2026 report, the median condo and townhouse sale price in its market was $223,750 in October, up 1.7% from September. Closed sales rose to 258 and median days on market fell to 72. New condo listings for October reached 648, up 42.7% from the month before, and supply rose to 10.5 months. For single-family homes in October, the median was $369,999, median days on market was 42 and supply stood at 7.5 months. The association's figures cover Lee and Hendry counties, excluding Bonita Springs and Estero.
The report describes October as a market that "found firmer footing" after several months of softening, while "still offering buyers an unusually wide range of options." Both readings hold for a condo buyer at The Forest. Prices have stopped falling. Even so, 10.5 months of supply means the condo segment has about three more months of inventory than single-family homes. Condo supply is 13.9% lower than in October 2025, so buyer leverage is real but smaller than it was a year ago.
In a bundled community, any discount a buyer wins on the home still sits beside a required club entry cost. At The Forest, a discount on a coach home or villa stays with the buyer. The club is a separate negotiation, and the buyer starts it from a different position.
Why the club is also courting buyers
A non-bundled club has to recruit every member. Its own marketing reflects that. The club's membership page advertises "Limited Time Opportunities" for new homeowners and for neighboring communities. It also mentions a second-club incentive for people who already belong to a club within 50 miles, and an extended incentive for Executive Golf members. Preview Memberships of two, three or four months are available once per family.
The club's July 31, 2026 post called late summer the best time to join, ahead of the seasonal rush. It also confirmed that the club offers both resident and non-resident memberships. For a buyer, the timing helps. A new homeowner who closes this season can ask about the new-homeowner offers before deciding whether to join. With a Preview Membership, they can also try the club for part of a season before choosing a full tier.
The club is also using a recently finished project to attract members. In a December 2024 announcement, The Forest laid out a renovation of the Bear Course covering greens, bunkers, fairways, cart paths, landscaping and water-saving measures. The club says the reimagined Bear Course reopened in late 2025. It pairs with the Bobcat Course for 36 holes. In the same July post, the club notes that Gulfshore Life named it "Best of Golf & Tennis" for eight straight years, 2019 through 2026. The clubhouse dining program is led by Chef Drew Tait, and the Gumbo Limbo Outdoor Tiki Bar sits alongside it. The terrace overlooks the Bear Course. A buyer this season joins after the renovation is finished, on a golf course that was rebuilt within the past year.
Putting the two decisions in order
The structure points to a sequence. First, settle on the home, using a condo market with 10.5 months of supply to negotiate the price, terms and timing. Next, call the club's membership office as a new homeowner and ask which incentives apply to your household and which tier fits how and when you play. A household can also decide on the Lifestyle or Racquets tier, or no membership at all, and still own inside the gate.
The real cost of living at The Forest depends on the household. Two buyers can pay the same price for neighboring villas and still spend very different amounts each year. One may join at the Family level, while the other plays only in summer on the Limited Golf tier. A bundled community can't give its owners that choice. In this market, that option has value.
Buyers who want to compare The Forest with other private clubs in the area can start with our Fort Myers luxury real estate overview.
Questions buyers ask about The Forest
Does buying a home at The Forest require joining the club? No. The club describes The Forest as a non-bundled community, so owners can choose whether to join.
Can someone who lives outside The Forest join? Yes. In its July 2026 post, the club says it has both resident and non-resident memberships.
Who qualifies for the Executive Membership? Households where the eldest member is under 54. It includes children up to age 25 and unlimited golf on all 36 holes.
At Abreu Group, we can talk through a purchase at The Forest as two decisions, the home and the club, before you commit to either. To review villas, coach homes and single-family homes inside the gate and how each fits the way your household plays, Schedule a Private Consultation.